How to Choose a Cold Email Outreach Software [7 Key Criteria]

Are you tired of spending countless hours crafting the perfect cold email only to have it land in your prospect’s spam folder?

Or maybe you’re frustrated with the low response rate and lack of personalization in your outreach efforts.

Well, fear not, because we’ve got just the solution for you.

In this article, we’re diving deep into the world of cold email outreach software and sharing with you the 7 key criteria that we highly consider when evaluating these tools.

When Do I Need a Cold Email Outreach Software

It might be difficult to know when to invest in cold email outreach tools. However, there are some clear signs that indicate that it’s time to consider investing in a tool to help with your outreach efforts.

If you find yourself spending a significant amount of time each week on manual outreach and not seeing the desired results, then it’s likely that a cold email outreach software will help you save time and streamline your efforts.

Moreover, if you’re having problems with low deliverability rates, poor prospecting and email verification, a lack of personalization, and inadequate follow-up or analytics, cold email outreach software can give the answers you need to boost your results.

By investing in the right software, you can take your outreach efforts to the next level and achieve better results in less time.

The 7 Criteria We Highly Consider in a Cold Email Software

Selecting the right software for cold email outreach is critical to your success. There are several alternatives on the market, but they are not all made equal.

To assist you in making an educated decision, we’ve outlined seven key criteria that we look for when choosing cold email outreach software. These criteria cover everything from deliverability and prospecting to personalization, follow-ups, analytics, and pricing.

By paying close attention to each of these criteria, you can guarantee that you choose a software that suits your needs and assists you in meeting your outreach objectives. Now, let’s get started and look at the seven criteria we strongly advise you to consider while selecting cold email outreach software.

Criteria 1 - Deliverability

When it comes to cold email outreach, deliverability is one of the most important factors to consider. This is because your emails need to reach the intended recipient’s inbox in order to have any chance of success.

To achieve the best possible deliverability rates, you’ll need a cold email outreach software with a wide range of essential features. These include email warmup tool functionality, which can help improve the reputation of your email address and increase deliverability rates over time.

Additionally, it’s important to select a software that can help your emails land in the primary inbox, rather than getting filtered into spam folders or promotions tabs. Email throttling and human-like sending can also be important, as this can help avoid triggering spam filters and ensure that your emails appear more natural and personalized.

Finally, a robust spam assessment feature can help you identify any issues with your emails that could be causing them to get filtered into spam folders. By selecting a cold email outreach software that prioritizes deliverability, you can increase the likelihood that your emails will reach their intended recipients and achieve the desired results.

woodpecker email analytics
Woodpecker email analytics

Criteria 2 - Prospecting & Email Verification

Prospecting and email verification are other important factors to consider while choosing a cold email outreach software. This is vital because you must guarantee that you are sending emails to the correct individuals and that the information is accurate and up to date.

To do this, you’ll need software with strong prospecting and email verification features. This includes elements like lead generation tools, which may assist you in identifying new prospects and growing your list.

A LinkedIn email finder may also be a useful tool for locating and validating email addresses for your target prospects. Finally, an email verification tool is necessary to ensure that your email list is accurate and up to date, hence improving deliverability and avoiding spending time and money on outdated or invalid contacts.

By selecting a cold email outreach software that prioritizes prospecting and email verification, you can be confident that you’re targeting the right people with accurate and up-to-date information.

persistiq luka
PersistIQ Luka

Criteria 3 - Personalization & Customizability

Personalization and customizability are other important criteria to consider when choosing cold email outreach software. This is due to the fact that personalization and customization may help your emails stand out from the crowd and boost the likelihood of a favorable response.

To do this, you’ll need a software with a variety of personalization and customization features. This includes cold email templates, which may save you time while also ensuring a consistent brand message throughout all of your outreach activities.

Moreover, dynamic graphics and videos may be powerful ways for engaging your audience and expressing your message more effectively.

You can design more engaging and effective outreach campaigns that are targeted to the individual requirements and preferences of your target audience by using cold email outreach software that emphasizes personalization and customizability.

Saleshandy email editor
Saleshandy email editor

Criteria 4 - Email Sequences & Follow-ups

Cold email sequences and follow-ups are essential parts of every successful cold email outreach effort. This is because a single email is sometimes insufficient to catch your target audience’s attention and drive the desired action. Instead, compose a sequence of well-crafted emails that build on one another and guide the recipient toward a certain objective.

You’ll need cold email outreach software with an email sequence builder to make this process easier. This tool may assist you in creating and managing a series of tailored and engaging emails aimed at nurturing leads and driving conversions.

It’s also critical to use software that allows you to pause email sequences when a recipient responds. This may help you prevent spamming or bombarding them with messages, as well as boost your overall engagement rates.

You may establish a more effective and efficient outreach plan that produces actual results by using cold email outreach software that optimizes email sequences and follow-ups.

snovio automation builder2
Snov.io automation builder

Criteria 5 - Multichannel Outreach

Any effective cold email marketing strategy must include multichannel outreach. Since not everybody replies to emails, you must also reach out to your target audience where they are most engaged.

To do so, you’ll require cold email outreach software with several contact channels. This includes features such as cold calling, SMS, and LinkedIn outreach.

Cold calling allows you to swiftly and simply contact leads over the phone and establish a more personal relationship.

Sending Bulk SMS messages may also be a great way for engaging leads and swiftly and efficiently providing crucial information. 

Lastly, LinkedIn outreach may be a powerful tool for engaging with prospects and building relationships on social media.

By selecting a cold email outreach software that prioritizes multichannel outreach, you can create a more diverse and effective outreach strategy that reaches your target audience where they are most active.

reply intent scoring
Reply.io email intent scoring

Criteria 6 - Analytics & Metrics

When it comes to evaluating the efficacy of your cold email outreach campaigns, analytics and metrics are critical. With the right tools, you can easily track the performance of your emails, test different subject lines and body text, and identify what’s working and what’s not.

That is why it is critical to use cold email outreach software that includes powerful analytics and metrics capability. This includes tools like dashboards that offer an overview of the performance of your campaign, as well as open rate and click-through rate tracking.

A/B testing is particularly important since it allows you to test multiple subject lines and body text to see what resonates with your target audience. Lastly, reporting on sales team metrics may give crucial insights into how your sales team is performing, allowing you to discover areas for improvement and optimize your sales process.

You can analyze the success of your cold email outreach campaigns and make data-driven decisions to enhance your performance over time if you have the necessary analytics and metrics tools at your disposal.

best cold email software - reply io analytics
Reply.io analytics

Criteria 7 - Pricing

Pricing is a key consideration when choosing cold email outreach software. You want to be sure you’re receiving good value for your money and that the software is within your price range. One important pricing criteria to consider is how the software’s pricing compares to other options on the market.

Take the time to study and evaluate different providers’ pricing plans so you can make an informed decision about which one is best for you. Another important factor to consider is whether the software includes a trial period.

Before committing to a long-term subscription, a trial period can be a great opportunity to test the software’s capabilities and assess whether it suits your needs.

Look for providers that offer a generous trial period, so you have enough time to fully explore the software’s features and make an informed decision about whether to invest in it for the long term.

Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing Cold Email Tools

Below are some frequently asked questions about our process for choosing the right cold email software.

How Do We Determine the Star Ratings?

We take our rating system seriously to help you make an informed decision about which cold email outreach software is right for you. We rate each of the seven criteria on a scale of 1 to 5 stars, with 5 stars being the highest rating.

Our ratings are based on our extensive research, which includes testing each software against the criteria listed. We also take into account customer reviews and feedback, as well as industry standards and best practices.

Once we have rated each of the criteria, we combine the scores to determine an overall rating for the software. This provides you with a clear and objective assessment of each software’s strengths and weaknesses, and helps you make an informed decision about which software is best suited for your needs.

How Do We Guarantee an Unbiased Review?

We take pride in giving honest and informative reviews to our readers. To guarantee that our evaluations are unbiased, we carefully and objectively investigate each software. We don’t just provide you with the positive features, but also the flaws of each software.

We personally test each program and ensure that our reviews are based on facts and real-world experience. By doing so, we ensure that our assessments are objective and that you can rely on our recommendations when selecting the best cold email outreach software for your needs.

Key Takeaways on How to Choose a Cold Email Software

In summary, choosing the right cold email outreach software can make or break your marketing campaign. The seven criteria we highly consider in a cold email software are: deliverability, prospecting and email verification, personalization and customizability, email sequences and follow-ups, multichannel outreach, analytics and metrics, and pricing.

Deliverability is important to ensure that your emails land in your prospects’ primary inboxes and not in their spam folders. Prospecting and email verification can help you find and verify the email addresses of your target audience. Personalization and customizability can make your emails stand out and increase your response rates.

Email sequences and follow-ups can help you automate your outreach and follow up with prospects. Multichannel outreach can help you reach prospects through different channels such as cold calling, SMS, and LinkedIn.

Analytics and metrics can help you track the success of your campaigns and optimize your strategies. Finally, pricing is a crucial factor to consider, especially for small businesses and startups.

It’s essential to examine each software carefully and provide an unbiased review that not only highlights the positive features but also the flaws of each software. We also tested each software first-hand to guarantee that our reviews are reliable and trustworthy.

By considering these criteria, you can choose the right cold email outreach software that suits your needs and budget, and maximize your marketing efforts.

To achieve the best results with email outreach, we recommend using a professional email automation software

13 best cold email platforms rated and compared

Picture of Erkki Muuga

Erkki Muuga

Erkki has over 10 years of experience as a software product manager and a proven track record in building and growing SaaS products. He has a keen eye for key differentiating factors and spotting truly valuable software features that enable business use cases.

Table of Contents

Scroll to Top