Cold Email Deliverability Guide and Best Practices Checklist

Let’s be real: getting your cold emails read can sometimes feel like trying to get a cat to take a selfie—frustrating and often unsuccessful. 

But, fear not! We’re about to turn you into the email whisperer. 

Say goodbye to the dreaded digital void of the spam folder, and hello to the spotlight of the inbox. 

With a sprinkle of wit and a solid grasp of cold email deliverability, you’re about to make your emails as irresistible as that ‘Skip Ad’ button. 

Ready to get your messages opened faster than a double-tap on a foodie’s Instagram post? Let’s dive in.

What Is Cold Email Deliverability?

Cold email deliverability is all about ensuring your email hits the inbox and avoiding the spam folder. Imagine you’ve crafted the perfect cold email, but if your deliverability is off, it’s like shouting into the void—no one’s going to hear you.

What Is Cold Email Deliverability?
What Is Cold Email Deliverability?

So, what makes an email cold as ice yet hot enough to get read? It’s not just what you say but how and where it lands. Spammers often get it wrong; they might throw in flashy images hoping to catch attention, but all they catch is the spam trap. 

That’s because email services are getting smart, sniffing out the spammers who think they’re clever by using images to confirm active addresses. They’re not fooling anyone. And while we’re debunking myths, let’s clear the air: whether you’re typing in Gmail or Yahoo, capital letters in email addresses don’t matter one bit.

What does count is your approach to keeping that email health score up, steering clear of those red flags that scream ‘spam’ to an email client. Stick to this mantra, and you’ll keep your cold emails away from the cold, dark corners of the spam bin.

Best Practices for Cold Email

Nailing cold email deliverability is like threading a needle in the digital world—you’ve got to be precise and on point. You want your emails to land in the inbox, not to disappear into the spam abyss. 

It’s all about the art of being warmly professional in a cold email. You’ve got to strike the right balance between being informative and not setting off any spammy alarm bells.

Here’s a quick best practices checklist to keep your cold emails feeling personal and welcome:

Best Practices for Cold Email
Best Practices for Cold Email

Follow these steps, and your cold emails will feel like a warm invite to a professional chat, and that’s the kind of email anyone would welcome with open arms.

Technical Aspects of Email Deliverability

Navigating the world of email deliverability is key to successful cold emailing. This guide highlights essential strategies: authenticating your email, adhering to provider guidelines, monitoring your health score, testing deliverability, maintaining a clean list, crafting engaging content, and simplifying the unsubscribe process.

Each step is critical for ensuring your emails land in the right inbox and garner positive engagement.

Technical Aspects of Email Deliverability
Technical Aspects of Email Deliverability

Authenticate Your Email

Authenticating your email is a critical first step in ensuring your messages reach the inbox. This process involves setting up SPF records to verify your domain’s authority to send emails, which helps prevent spoofing and phishing. 

Incorporating DKIM adds a layer of trust by attaching a digital signature to your outbound emails, confirming their legitimacy.

Lastly, a DMARC policy is your set of instructions to email providers on how to handle your emails if they fail SPF or DKIM checks. Think of these three components as the foundational pillars of building a secure and trusted email program.

Email process diagram
Email process diagram

Understand Provider Guidelines

Every email provider has a set of rules that senders should adhere to for optimal deliverability. For instance, familiarizing yourself with Gmail’s bulk sender guidelines can make a significant difference in achieving Google email deliverability.

These guidelines offer insights into best practices for sending large volumes of mail, such as how to avoid being marked as spam. Similarly, understanding Outlook’s Junk Email Filter and SmartScreen filter criteria can help you adjust your email strategy to meet Microsoft’s standards, ensuring your emails stay clear of the dreaded junk folder.

Monitor Your Email Health Score

Monitoring your email health score is akin to keeping a close watch on your personal credit score—it’s a measure of your email sending reputation. Tools like Sender Score or Talos Intelligence provide a numeric score based on your email sending practices, such as the volume of email sent, complaint rates, and how often you hit spam traps. 

If your score is low, it indicates to ISPs that your emails could be unwanted or unsolicited, prompting a need for corrective actions like enhancing list hygiene or revising email content.

Test Your Emails

Before launching your campaign, it’s essential to test your emails. This involves using specialized inbox testing tools to see if your messages are landing in the inbox or spam folder across various email providers. It’s also prudent to send test emails to personal accounts you own on platforms such as Gmail, Yahoo, and Outlook. 

This step is your quality assurance process, ensuring that each element of your email, from subject lines to content layout, is optimized for deliverability.

Keep Your Lists Clean

Maintaining a clean email list is non-negotiable for high email deliverability. Regularly removing unengaged subscribers can significantly improve your sender reputation and ensure higher engagement rates. 

Using a double opt-in mechanism is also effective—it adds an extra step for users to confirm their subscription, thereby verifying their interest and engagement level. This practice helps in building a list that’s not only compliant but also more likely to interact with your emails.

Pay Attention to Email Content

The content of your email is crucial in determining its fate. Avoiding the use of spam-trigger phrases and focusing on creating relevant, engaging content will increase the likelihood of your email being well-received.

Furthermore, a well-formatted email with an appropriate text-to-image ratio makes your message accessible and appealing, encouraging recipients to read and engage. Careful attention to the composition of your email content can thus have a direct positive impact on deliverability rates.

If you’re unsure about your email content, utilize AI writing tools to help you start crafting your message based on the email tone that matches your voice.

Provide Easy Unsubscribe Options

Finally, it’s vital to respect your subscribers’ choices by providing a clear, easy-to-find unsubscribe link. Not only is this practice part of adhering to anti-spam laws, but it also helps maintain a clean list by allowing disinterested parties to opt out easily.

A straightforward unsubscribe process can minimize spam complaints and contribute to a more engaged, active subscriber base, which in turn, benefits your overall email deliverability.

How Email Warm Ups Help with Email Deliverability

You might not think about it, but warming up your email is like getting your muscles ready before a big workout. It’s crucial for making sure your emails actually get seen. 

Picture this: you start with a light jog, sending a few emails, and gradually increase the volume. This tells providers like Google and Outlook, “Hey, I’m a regular here, not a spammer.” And it’s not just about dodging the spam folder; a good warm-up can boost your overall email health score

This means your emails are more likely to land where you want them, right in the inbox, making email deliverability issues less of a headache. You keep your list clean, engagement high, and by the time you’re at full speed, your emails are hitting the inbox consistently.

So, take the time to warm up your email—it’s like a trust handshake with the email world.

Crafting Your Message With High Deliverability Chance

Crafting an email that’s got a high chance of breezing through to the inbox is part art, part science. You start by getting personal; no one likes feeling like they’re just another number. Use their name, reference a recent event, make it feel like you’re talking right to them.

This helps keep your cold email meaning relevant and far from the cold email vs spam battleground. You also keep it short and sweet because, let’s face it, everyone’s time is precious. Here’s your quick checklist for an email with wings:

How to Craft an Email With High Deliverability Chance
How to Craft an Email With High Deliverability Chance

Personalize Your Greeting

Kick off with a friendly “Hi [Name],” to instantly grab attention. Personalization is like a digital handshake; it makes the reader feel recognized and valued, which can be a deciding factor in whether they engage with your email or not.

Keep Your Subject Lines Clear

A straightforward subject line works wonders. Avoid overused sales phrases that scream spam. Instead, opt for clarity and relevance. A good subject line reflects the email’s content, so your recipient knows what to expect before they even open it.

Use A Familiar Sender Name

Whether it’s your name or your brand’s, consistency in the sender field builds recognition. When recipients see a name they’ve seen before, they’re more likely to trust the content of the email. Familiarity reduces the risk of your emails being marked as spam and improves deliverability.

Optimize The Email Body For Skimmability

In our fast-paced world, no one wants to wade through a wall of text. Use bullet points and break the content into short, digestible paragraphs. This approach respects your reader’s time and increases the chances they’ll read through and engage with your message.

Include A Clear Call-To-Action (CTA)

After all, you’re emailing for a reason. Make it crystal clear what you’d like the recipient to do next, whether it’s clicking through to an article or checking out a sale. A well-crafted CTA can significantly boost your response rate.

Test Your Email For Spam Flags

Before you send your masterpiece, run it through a spam email tester. This will help you catch any content that might trigger spam filters, from risky words to image-heavy designs. It’s like a rehearsal before the live show, ensuring your email is set to make the best impression when it hits the stage of the inbox.

Tools to Help Maximize Your Email Deliverability

If you’re serious about maximizing your email deliverability, having the right tools in your arsenal is non-negotiable.

Tools to Help Maximize Your Email Deliverability
Tools to Help Maximize Your Email Deliverability

Cold Email Software

Think of cold email software as the quarterback of your outreach strategy. It’s more than just a tool; it’s the driving force that propels your emails forward. This software should give you the power to craft personalized messages en masse, track your opens and clicks, and manage your contacts effectively. 

The real magic lies in its ability to run spam tests before you hit send, ensuring your cold email deliverability rate stays robust.

Email Warm Up Tools

Warm up tools for your email are like the essential stretches before a marathon. They’re not just for show—they’re about getting your email ‘muscles’ ready for the big race. 

These tools send messages from your account at a growing volume, earning the trust of ISPs and building up your sender score. Think of it as your email’s personal trainer, helping it get into peak condition to make sure your email deliverability guide sees the light of day.

Custom Domain

A custom email domain does more than just polish your brand’s image—it’s your badge of authenticity in the digital realm. By using a custom domain, you’re telling email servers, “I’m in it for the long haul.”

This commitment is a powerful trust signal, influencing your email health score positively and making your cold email meaning much more than just another sales pitch.

What Is A Custom Domain?
What Is A Custom Domain?

DNS Server

Your DNS server is essentially the compass that guides your emails through the labyrinth of the internet. Correct DNS configuration is critical—it ensures that your messages don’t raise any red flags that lead to the dreaded spam folder.

By setting up SPF and DKIM records, you’re not just dotting the i’s and crossing the t’s—you’re building a reputation with every email you send.

Frequently Asked Questions on Cold Email Deliverability

You’ve got questions on cold email deliverability, and I’ve got the answers that cut through the noise.

Does personalization affect my cold email deliverability?

You bet it does. Tossing in a recipient’s name isn’t just about being friendly—it tells the email service you’re not shooting off emails to a list you bought at a virtual back alley. Personalizing content shows that you know who you’re talking to, and this attention to detail keeps your email away from the spam dungeon.

Remember, personalization goes beyond the greeting; it’s about tailoring the content to meet the interests and needs of your recipient, which dramatically reduces your spam rate and increases the chances of your email being opened and engaged with.

Does a tracking pixel affect deliverability?

It sure can. A tracking pixel is like a digital spy—hidden within your email, letting you know who’s opened it. But here’s the kicker: some email providers see this as a privacy concern and might be wary of your messages. If they sniff out a tracking pixel, it could be a red flag, leading them to side-eye your email straight to the spam folder.

To keep your deliverability up, use tracking pixels wisely and transparently. Let your recipients know why you’re using them—it’s part of being upfront, which can actually improve trust and engagement. After all, maintaining a clean reputation is key for your cold email deliverability.

Should you send files as attachments or as links?

When deciding between sending files as attachments or as links, it’s crucial to consider both security and deliverability. 

Attachments can quickly bloat the size of your email, potentially triggering spam filters or being rejected by the recipient’s server due to size limits. They also carry a risk of spreading malware, making recipients wary of opening them. 

On the other hand, links to files stored on trusted cloud services not only keep your email sleek and quick to load but also signal to your recipients that it’s safe to view the documents.

Plus, providing links allows for easy tracking of who has accessed the file, offering valuable engagement metrics. In the end, opting for links over attachments is often the safer and more efficient choice for both sender and receiver.

How does email list segmentation play into deliverability?

Email list segmentation is like having VIP lines in a club; it makes everyone feel special and reduces chaos. By segmenting your list, you’re ensuring that the right eyes see the most relevant content. It’s a step beyond personalization—it’s about relevance at scale.

ISPs love this because it means lower bounce rates, higher engagement, and fewer spam complaints. Segmenting your list shows that you’re not just blasting out messages to everyone, but you’re carefully choosing who receives what, which significantly enhances your email health score and deliverability.

Key Takeaways on Cold Email Deliverability

Alright, let’s wrap this up. We’ve ventured through the ins and outs of cold email deliverability, uncovering the not-so-secret secrets to keeping your emails out of the spam folder

We talked about the big no-nos, like overlooking personalization and sending emails at odd hours. We also highlighted the importance of tools like cold email software, warm-up tools, and the almighty custom domain to keep your emails looking legit and landing right.

Remember how we stressed the importance of DNS settings? They’re the unsung heroes in your email’s journey to the inbox. And let’s not forget about segmentation—tailoring your audience so you’re not just shouting into the void but actually engaging with folks who want to listen.

We dived into the nitty-gritty of tracking pixels, too. They’re handy, but you’ve got to be smart about them. Transparency is your best friend here. Use it to build trust and keep those email health scores golden.

So, there you have it. Stick to these pointers, and you’ll be sending out cold emails that not only reach inboxes but also might just get you those nods of approval you’re after. It’s all about being smart, respectful, and a little bit savvy with your email strategy. 

Keep it clean, keep it relevant, and keep those lines of communication open. That’s the name of the game in the world of cold email deliverability.

To achieve the best results with email outreach, we recommend using a professional email automation software

13 best cold email platforms rated and compared

Picture of Edgar Abong

Edgar Abong

Edgar is a skilled software developer with a passion for building and evaluating software products. His expertise in software development enables him to provide in-depth evaluations of software products. He can draw out insights about features, functionality and user experience.

Table of Contents

Scroll to Top